July 9, 2025 | 17:14 GMT +7

  • Click to copy
Monday- 13:38, 13/11/2023

US pork industry is still fighting Prop 12

(VAN) The US pork industry is not giving up its fight against Proposition 12. Certain Republican senators are therefore aiming to issue a counteracting act.
Group housed sows at a farm in Indiana. Photo: Vincent ter Beek

Group housed sows at a farm in Indiana. Photo: Vincent ter Beek

Proposition 12 is a California state law from 2018, also known as the “farm animal confinement initiative.” It will take effect  on January 1, 2024. It requires that pork meat sold within the state of California, the largest US state market for pork, must meet certain sow housing requirements related to freedom of movement and larger floor space per pig.

In addition, in 2016, the state of Massachusetts passed Question 3 (Q3), which is similar to Prop 12. However, it goes further in that it prevents the shipment of non-compliant pork through the state, affecting several state markets.

An act to counteract

The Supreme Court upheld Prop 12 in May 2023. Now, to counteract this, 2 Republican senators introduced a piece of legislation called “The Ending Agricultural Trade Suppression Act” (which technically is a bill until approved by Congress, ed.). The act is supported by the National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) and the American Farm Bureau Federation, as well as almost 3 dozen co-sponsors in the US House of Representatives and 13 senators (besides the 2 who introduced it in the US Senate).

However, a letter against the act has been signed by other Republican legislators. They state that the act, “as applied in this circumstance, it is at odds with our foundational Republican principles of states’ rights, national sovereignty and fair competition.”

This group is concerned that the act would provide WH Group, a Chinese company that owns the largest US pork producer Smithfield Foods, “with a mechanism to bypass state-level laws and rapidly acquire even more American land and pork industry assets with no restraints at all.”

Feasibility of Prop 12 and similar legislation

There are those, such as Dr Monique Pairis-Garcia (associate professor, veterinarian at North Carolina State University and columnist at Pig Progress), who believe the US industry can manage to find ways to comply with newly-introduced standards. However, others at the World Pork Congress were of the opposite view. Michael Formica, NPPC chief legal strategist, stated that Prop 12 is “catastrophic for farmers in Iowa” and “also for consumers in California” due to increased pork prices in that state.

Dr Steve Meyer, an agricultural economist at Kerns and Associates, explained further that because non-compliant pork will no longer be able to be sold in California next year, it will be introduced into other US states, leading to an oversupply outside California. He noted that “the price of pork will have to drop 10-15% cutoff value per hundredweight, and prices are already low.”

Compliance already occurring

However, about 2 years ago, 2 of the largest US pork companies, Tyson Foods and Hormel have already agreed to comply with Prop 12. Canadian pork is also sold in the US, and major Canadian integrated pork producer Maple Leaf Foods has already transitioned to open housing for gestating sows. Quebec-based duBreton produces a line of ‘humane-certified’ pork that complies with Prop 12. In addition, several farm equipment companies are producing Prop-12 compliant housing options.

HD

(PP)

Illegal loggers profit from Brazil’s carbon credit projects

Illegal loggers profit from Brazil’s carbon credit projects

(VAN) How a system designed to protect the world’s biggest rainforest is funding businesses with a track record of illegal deforestation.

Cage-free countdown: UK retailers face 2025 deadline

Cage-free countdown: UK retailers face 2025 deadline

(VAN) Pressure is growing on companies to adopt the cage-free commitment for their egg supplies. Many food companies said their eggs would be from cage-free systems by the end of this year (2025).

Droughts worldwide pushing tens of millions towards starvation

Droughts worldwide pushing tens of millions towards starvation

(VAN) Water shortages hitting crops, energy and health as crisis gathers pace amid climate breakdown.

Green Climate Fund approves a record $300 million for FAO-designed projects in Papua New Guinea, Saint Lucia and the Sahel

Green Climate Fund approves a record $300 million for FAO-designed projects in Papua New Guinea, Saint Lucia and the Sahel

(VAN) The initiatives focus on forestry management, fisheries transformation and land restoration.

FAO urges collective action for food security, climate and development challenges in Africa.

FAO urges collective action for food security, climate and development challenges in Africa.

(VAN) Director-General QU Dongyu addresses the 6th AU-EU Agriculture Ministerial Conference.

Science meets soil: High-tech solutions elevate China's agricultural development

Science meets soil: High-tech solutions elevate China's agricultural development

(VAN) In the suburbs of Beijing, there is an agricultural center spanning over 150 hectares dedicated to research, demonstration, and application of high-tech and precision agriculture.

Plant-derived fertilizer additive boosts yields and cuts emissions

Plant-derived fertilizer additive boosts yields and cuts emissions

(VAN) Researchers from the Institute of Applied Ecology of the Chinese Academy of Sciences have developed a new environmentally friendly fertilizer additive that significantly enhances crop yields while reducing emissions of harmful gases.

Read more